|
Article posted in
![]() Truth ![]() Score: 85854 Currently located in Northwest Portland
Comments: 793 Articles: 250 Events: 148 Classifieds: 2 Photos: 928 Places Added: 448 Edits: 49581 Tags & Votes: 7078 |
||
LocationTags
immigrationimmigration 1 Person agrees with this tagging 0 People disagree 1 other items also have this tag mexican 1 Person agrees with this tagging 0 People disagree 13 other items also have this tag mexico 1 Person agrees with this tagging 0 People disagree 1 other items also have this tag racism 1 Person agrees with this tagging 0 People disagree 0 other items also have this tag xenophobia 1 Person agrees with this tagging 0 People disagree 0 other items also have this tag CLICK TO VOTE Total - Above the Fold: 8 Vote at Vote at Vote at Vote at Vote at Vote at Vote at Vote at Article: In Portland, Biggest Obama Rally Yet Draws 75,000 - Coverage Wrapup 3307 4 15 in The Truthy Dispatch Article: D.F. in the Pearl and Taqueria Nueve on NE 28th have both closed
922 2 2 in The Truthy Dispatch |
||
Score: 2255
Currently located in Beaverton
Joined: 12:21am 8/24/2006
Comments: 102
Articles: 31
Events: 1
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 70
Places Added: 8
Edits: 153
Tags & Votes: 276
Thats whack, it must have been a joke or prank..
Score: 19
Currently located in Earth
Joined: 4:00pm 10/9/2007
Comments: 2
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 1
Edits: 3
Tags & Votes: 6
Suckapunch, I am sorry to inform you that this kind of thing is not a joke or a prank, although the author probably thought it was funny. People think like this all the time. Or rather, don't think, and act like this without consideration of the deep influence this sort of hate perpetrates.
Score: 2255
Currently located in Beaverton
Joined: 12:21am 8/24/2006
Comments: 102
Articles: 31
Events: 1
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 70
Places Added: 8
Edits: 153
Tags & Votes: 276
Excuse me, but If you think Truth posted it as a joke you're probably mistaken. I Highly doubt he posted it as a joke.. But my thought was perhaps some Prick Kid re aranged the lettering..
Either way its disgusting.. and im sure no one here thinks of it amusing..
Score: 85854
Currently located in Northwest Portland
Joined: 12:00am 1/1/2006
Comments: 793
Articles: 250
Events: 148
Classifieds: 2
Photos: 928
Places Added: 448
Edits: 49581
Tags & Votes: 7078
im assuming eliahu meant the author if the billboard, not me. I run into this 'blame the immigrants' attitude all the time, so im pretty sure the billboard was intentional. In the video u can see some people who just looove the billboard. Couching hate and fear in humor makes it seem more innocuous, but it's still hate nonetheless.
Score: 2255
Currently located in Beaverton
Joined: 12:21am 8/24/2006
Comments: 102
Articles: 31
Events: 1
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 70
Places Added: 8
Edits: 153
Tags & Votes: 276
Its still hate.
and thats the Bottum line..
I see it every day.. I hear it every day when talking to people who complain about people from India.. like I said.. Its Disgusting and I'm glad the people I associate myself with arent that way..
great post G.
Score: 3
Currently located in Hillsboro
Joined: 11:44am 11/21/2007
Comments: 3
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
Hate is something you do to people. Humor is something that makes you laugh. My finding that billboard funny and witty is completely independent of how I feel for Mexicans, immigrants, the diaspora, etc. I've got no problem with immigrants, illegal or legal; I don't dislike Hispanic people. Because I laugh at this billboard, I am racist?
The problem with political correctness is it doesn't let us have any fun anymore. Everyone assumes race-based humor is rooted in hate. It's rooted in stereotypes, it's rooted in misconceptions, it's rooted in caricaturizatio n, but how is that any different from what we see on sitcoms and Saturday Night Live? Nobody accuses them of "hating" everyone they make fun of.
Score: 19
Currently located in Earth
Joined: 4:00pm 10/9/2007
Comments: 2
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 1
Edits: 3
Tags & Votes: 6
Indeed my comment above was in reference to the author of the billboard, not of this blog whom I support.
BrigntheRain, you are dead wrong. If you need some more persuading go check the Nazi archives and their 'humorous' depiction of Jews leading up to the Holocaust. It is unfortunate that humor is so often used to persecute people, races, religions, orientations, ect... but it is reality. Wit is not a excuse to further hate. And that is what this is.
It disgusts me.
Score: 85854
Currently located in Northwest Portland
Joined: 12:00am 1/1/2006
Comments: 793
Articles: 250
Events: 148
Classifieds: 2
Photos: 928
Places Added: 448
Edits: 49581
Tags & Votes: 7078
Unlike SNL or other comedy that exposes stereotypes, this isn't very 'tongue in cheek', and given the brief and in-your-face nature of the billboard, it is hard to believe the owner of it is 'just trying to have fun'. More than likely, he/she is using humor as an insidious way to get across a hateful message that would be easier to dismiss if it weren't wrapped in some innocent sounding humor.
I see where you are coming from BringTheRain, and it is definitely a fine line - one I'm not sure I can clearly see, but this billboard seemed over the top to me ;)
Welcome to Public Press and thanks for commenting.
Score: 2255
Currently located in Beaverton
Joined: 12:21am 8/24/2006
Comments: 102
Articles: 31
Events: 1
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 70
Places Added: 8
Edits: 153
Tags & Votes: 276
This is an intense discussion, to each his own, and in no way am I saying someone shouldn't find the humor in this.
My take is I just don't know how someone could be so hateful. Its bad taste and I'm not really down for the statement its making.. Its rude and it was made to draw blood, not laughter.
IMO
Score: 1
Currently located in Downtown Portland
Joined: 12:05pm 11/21/2007
Comments: 1
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
This billboard (and its owner) have been around for 30 years or so. Its messages tend to the right, but not always. This billboard's been in the press from time to time.
Score: 85854
Currently located in Northwest Portland
Joined: 12:00am 1/1/2006
Comments: 793
Articles: 250
Events: 148
Classifieds: 2
Photos: 928
Places Added: 448
Edits: 49581
Tags & Votes: 7078
Ah yes, I think I've seen some messages on this board before now that I think about it. I'm remembering them being more religious and less political. Welcome to the site Atak.
Score: 2255
Currently located in Beaverton
Joined: 12:21am 8/24/2006
Comments: 102
Articles: 31
Events: 1
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 70
Places Added: 8
Edits: 153
Tags & Votes: 276
Way more religeous than racial.. I wouldnt even call it political.
Score: 1
Currently located in Portland
Joined: 1:12pm 11/21/2007
Comments: 1
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
How dare the owner of that billboard post such a message on it. What gives him the right to think that he has such freedom of speech. Oh.....wait.... .
Whoever owns it has always had random political snipes on it which would certainly get someone irritated....an d this one is no different.
Score: 2
Currently located in Vancouver
Joined: 2:32pm 11/21/2007
Comments: 1
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 1
If you have lived in the Northwest for any length of time and have travelled up to Seattle from Portland, you have seen this sign many, many times. The person who fills this sign with different saying and witicisms has been doing this or their family has for at least 40 years. Sometimes it's funny, sometimes it's tacky, sometimes it's insightful. But hears what I don't get. Where in this billboard is there hate? It speaks of a population of the worlds society known to cross our borders illegally. It makes light of it. Big deal! I'll bet you a million bucks most Mexican's that see that sign are laughing their heads off! Why? Because they are here and not down in Mexico! Because if they put up a sign like that down in Mexico, the goverment might just intercede. They won't here, because it's called freedom of speech!
Embrace your culture. Don't conform to the norm. Learn to laugh at yourself and embrace your freedoms. Above all develop a thicker skin and watch comedy central for a change. Maybe a program like "Mind of Mencia"!!!
Score: 85854
Currently located in Northwest Portland
Joined: 12:00am 1/1/2006
Comments: 793
Articles: 250
Events: 148
Classifieds: 2
Photos: 928
Places Added: 448
Edits: 49581
Tags & Votes: 7078
Thanks for your comment "getalife". I don't like this billboard for the same reason I don't like Mind of Mencia - it's too easy, it's too generalized, and it can easily be interpreted as quite hurtful. Unlike Dave Chappelle or SNL, this type of humor doesn't make fun of racism by imitating it in an over the top fashion, but rather enforces racism by embracing a casual attitude toward stereotypical taunts.
As I said earlier, it is a fine line that you can't always find, but as a first generation immigrant, this billboard bothers me much like Mind of Mencia does, while I can have a great time watching Chappelle and SNL.
Score: 3
Currently located in Hillsboro
Joined: 11:44am 11/21/2007
Comments: 3
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
I think you've got it backwards, eliahu77. The Holocaust was not about the depiction of Jews, it was about the slaughter of Jews. This billboard is not about the persecution of Mexicans unless it inspires somebody to persecute Mexicans, and it's doubtful this billboard alone is going to accomplish that.
Billboards don't hate. People hate. Saying that someone can't say something witty, based on a stereotype or extreme example of an existing situation, because it might spawn racism is like saying people can't drive, because some drivers are reckless and will, inevitably, kill someone. I don't hate anyone, I don't look down on anyone. Is my laughing at this billboard, then, a manifestation of some inner hatred of Mexicans?
Call it satire, call it tasteless, call it sophomoric, but don't call it hate speech.
Score: 1
Currently located in Earth
Joined: 6:24am 11/22/2007
Comments: 1
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
If you think it's hate speech, Perhaps you need to look into yourself. i see a funny joke that doesn't say "I Hate" anywhere. Give it a break go ahead and laugh. My Mexican friends are OK with it.
Score: 1
Currently located in Earth
Joined: 6:38am 11/22/2007
Comments: 1
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
It's not only funny, it's true. The crime rate is proof enough. Politically correct robots are the new church ladies, always finding a way to be holier than everyone else.
Score: 1
Currently located in Vancouver
Joined: 8:19am 11/22/2007
Comments: 1
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
Actually, it's no joke -- no kids rearranged the letters. The billboard, which is near Chehalis, is on a man's private property. There's been discussion about it for years, since many times he's offended various groups of people. But since it's on private property ... anyway. He posts all kinds of crazy stuff up there. This message is in line with all the other ones I've seen for the better part of two decades.
Score: 1
Currently located in Earth
Joined: 8:41am 11/22/2007
Comments: 1
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
Freedom of Speech. This billboard and its author have been stationary posting political and religious comments for several decades. This is freedom of the press, even though its a one man show. We can disagree with his viewpoints by posting our own notes here, or purchasing our own billboards.
Score: 1
Currently located in Oregon City
Joined: 10:24am 11/22/2007
Comments: 1
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
Either the truth can hurt or we can just lauph about it. It seems that Portland's liberals have nothing better to do than complain.
Score: 1
Currently located in Earth
Joined: 10:24am 11/22/2007
Comments: 1
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
I am delighted that the owner of this I-5 billboard has once again ( as for the past 40 years) managed to irritate those liberals and so-called tolerance lovers by exercising freedom of speech. There is no such thing as an" "illegal immigrant". The operative word is illegal therefore that makes all illegal aliens criminals. I don't care a wit about the signs message hurting someone's feelings. There is no constitutional right that a person is entitled to go through life immune to having their precious feelings shielded from something they disagree with. Oh- as a final shot, there is nothing"correct " about PC. It is insanity and a code word falsely claiming that there is but one viewpoint. I have made a hobby of going out of my way to challange and get in the faces of those who demand that I exceed to the wishes of the PC crowd. It warms my heart to see the stunned looks on their faces whenever I throw their looney arguments back at them.
Score: 2255
Currently located in Beaverton
Joined: 12:21am 8/24/2006
Comments: 102
Articles: 31
Events: 1
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 70
Places Added: 8
Edits: 153
Tags & Votes: 276
I'm glad we live in a country that allows us the freedom of speech, and opinion. As my opinion still stands, its dis-tasteful. As an act of "Freedom of Speech" I hold my ground when I say its disgusting and not needed.
and thats my opinion, this is my Billboard. I don't need to go out and purchase some plastic letters to make my point.
Whats gonna happen is some Mexican is going to end up going ballistic and shoot the guy that put it up.. Freedom of Speech has sure changed into "The Right to Discriminate" these days.
Score: 1
Currently located in Los Angeles
Joined: 12:05pm 11/22/2007
Comments: 1
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
Man I forgot how Left Wing and PC Portland has become until I read the comments here. 12 million illegals break into the country by far mainly from Mexico and we are not supposed to say or do anything. Well anything that is, other than giving them free access to our schools, hospitals, roads and social services. I have nothing against the immigrants who come here legally, as we all are originally immigrants but why should we accept law breaking as normative behavior? I dare you to go to Mexico and violate their immigration laws and we'll see how well you are treated. The reason why we have quotas in the first place is to help ensure that the country can absorb and assimilate them into the greater culture. Their actions undermine that greatly, which is why we are now becoming Balkanized. Come to LA to take a peek at your future dear friends.
Score: 1
Currently located in Oregon
Joined: 12:33pm 11/22/2007
Comments: 1
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
Maybe if we actually dealt with the issue of ILLEGALS, and didn’t try to confuse it with IMMIGRATION (they are definitely NOT the same thing), we’d solve a big, big problem and not have to get worked up over signs and sayings.
Score: 3
Currently located in Hillsboro
Joined: 11:44am 11/21/2007
Comments: 3
Articles: 0
Events: 0
Classifieds: 0
Photos: 0
Places Added: 0
Edits: 0
Tags & Votes: 0
The issue isn't illegal immigration, either. The issue is the obscene amount of wealth we have in this country compared to the obscene poverty of much of Mexico. You would do the exact same thing if you were them.
Rather than build a wall to (try to) keep people out, we need to find a way to keep them from wanting to come. Economic health in Mexico is good for the economic health of the United States. (By the way, did you see that Alex Rodriguez salary calculator (http://www.star ledger.com/str/ indexpage/payro lls/arod2.asp) ? It'll take me 5 years to make what he makes in a game. A-Rod will make more in each plate appearance than the average Mexican citizen will in four years. Do you really think it's likely to stop?
And Suckapunch - Tell me how this billboard discriminates against anyone? Discrimination, in the racial sense, is denying someone access based on their ethnicity. If the billboard owner also runs a RV park that doesn't allow Hispanics in, he is discriminating.
Interesting that no Hispanics have (openly) come forward on this post to share their thoughts.
Score: 85854
Currently located in Northwest Portland
Joined: 12:00am 1/1/2006
Comments: 793
Articles: 250
Events: 148
Classifieds: 2
Photos: 928
Places Added: 448
Edits: 49581
Tags & Votes: 7078
Here is a post from last year on another blog with some other sayings from this billboard: http://seattles t.com/2006/05/2 2/whats_up_in_t he_i5_corridor. php
I am a staunch proponent of freedom of speech (hence this website!), so I understand the cost - you accept the worst of free speech to protect the best of it.
I didn't post this just because I was offended by it, I posted it because it clearly displays (especially in the CNN video) the deeper issue here - there are a lot of people who are really angry at illegal immigrants, and it hurts me when I see them slip down the slope and translate that into anger towards Mexicans in general. I am probably on the most liberal extreme of this spectrum, I think our immigration policy is too strict and we aren't doing enough to help our neighbors.
Thanks to all for the hearty discussion and happy thanksgiving to everyone. Welcome all new members who signed up to comment - please feel free to start your own column or post anything you'd like.
You people on the west side have no idea!!! Come to Yakima and see for yourselves! Se Habla espanol? What a bunch of crap!!!!!
YOu have to understand that this is just the tip of the ice berg on how all of us hard working Americans who's tax dollars go to feed and provide free health and welfare funds and shit like this for this illegal wabs. Let them all rott on hell and send them back to the shit hole they came from? I am tired of seeing 60 something year old ewet back who have been here in America for like 30 years and still don't speak english. Learn to speak english or get the fuck out. And anyone who doesn't like what I say, Freedon of Speech!!!!!! baby. Send all these illegal wabs and their childern, even if they were born here, and all of their 50 family members back to mexico. NO SE Puede!!!!! NO Se Puede!!!!!!!!!! !!